Surgeon explaining meniscal root tears using a knee model during a consultation

Meniscal Root Tears

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35755791/

Diagnosis, Consequences and Treatment

Evidence Base

Banovetz MT, Roethke LC, Rodriguez AN, LaPrade RF. Meniscal Root Tears: A Decade of Research on their Relevant Anatomy, Biomechanics, Diagnosis, and Treatment. Arch Bone Jt Surg. 2022 May;10(5):366-380. doi: 10.22038/ABJS.2021.60054.2958. PMID: 35755791; PMCID: PMC9194705.

Key Points

  • Meniscal root tears are serious injuries that can behave like complete loss of the meniscus
  • They significantly increase contact pressures in the knee, similar to having the meniscus removed
  • Untreated root tears can rapidly lead to cartilage damage and arthritis
  • Repair of the root can restore more normal knee mechanics
  • Early diagnosis and treatment are important for the best outcomes

What is a meniscal root tear?

The meniscus is anchored to the bone at its front and back attachments, known as the roots.

A root tear occurs when this attachment is disrupted.

Knee diagram showing the meniscal root and forces transmitted through the meniscus

Knee MRI illustrating the ghost sign associated with a meniscal root tear

This means the meniscus can no longer function properly, even if the rest of it looks intact.

Why is this important?

When the root is torn:

  • The meniscus is no longer able to distribute load effectively
  • Contact pressures in the knee increase significantly
  • This is biomechanically similar to removing the meniscus completely

Diagram showing cartilage wear associated with a degenerative meniscal root tear

This can lead to:

  • Rapid cartilage wear
  • Progression to arthritis
  • Ongoing pain and swelling

What causes a root tear?

Root tears can occur in two main ways:

  • Traumatic injuries, often in younger patients during sport
  • Degenerative tears, more common in middle-aged patients

Degenerative root tears are often associated with:

  • Sudden onset pain
  • A “pop” or sharp pain without major trauma
  • Early arthritis changes

What did the study show?

This paper brings together the current understanding of meniscal root tears.

It highlights that:

  • Root tears significantly alter knee biomechanics
  • They are frequently underdiagnosed
  • MRI can help identify the injury, but careful assessment is needed

Treatment options

Non-operative treatment

  • May be considered in low-demand patients
  • Does not restore normal knee mechanics
  • Often associated with progression of arthritis

Meniscal root repair

  • Aims to reattach the meniscus to the bone
  • Can restore more normal load distribution
  • Best outcomes seen in patients with:
    • minimal arthritis
    • good alignment
    • early diagnosis

Other options

In more advanced cases, additional procedures may be required, such as:

  • Osteotomy to correct alignment
  • Joint replacement in severe arthritis

What does this mean for you?

Meniscal root tears are an important and sometimes overlooked cause of knee pain.

Key messages:

  • They are more serious than a standard meniscus tear
  • Early diagnosis can change treatment and outcomes
  • Repair can help preserve the knee and delay arthritis in suitable patients

Key considerations

  • Not all root tears are suitable for repair
  • Outcomes depend on cartilage health and alignment
  • Early specialist assessment is important